AMNESTY INTERNATIONAL KEEPS SILENCE OVER MAOIST BRUTALITIES IN INDIA

R. Vijayan rvijayan.vijayan@gmail.com
To: press@amnesty.org
Wed, Mar 3, 2010 at 5:16 PM

03-03-2010

To
The Amnesty International

Respected Sir,

SUB: MAOIST BRUTALITIES IN WEST BENGAL & OTHER PARTS OF INDIA

Most respected Sir,

As an ordinary humble citizen of the country, I would like to invite your immediate attention to the following fact.

Your esteemed organization had taken 14 unfortunate deaths at Nandigram on 14-03-2007 in West Bengal in India very seriously and even issued next day a press statement promptly condemning the incident and the Left Front Government. This action on your part had received widespread coverage in the media at that time both within the country and abroad.

But you did not use even a single word to condemn the provocation of the rainbow alliance of virgin Marxists, ultra communists, political opportunists, renegades, NGOs, fundamentalists, right wing and left wing intelligentsia; all fervently anti-CPI (M) culminating in these 14 unfortunate deaths. Today also you maintain complete silence over the ghastly murders committed by the Maoists in West Bengal and other parts of the country. As a result, this has raised many a questions in the minds of the people about the impartiality and objectivity of your esteemed organization.

It is needless to mention that the Indian Railway Minister Mamata Banerjee's greatest achievements in West Bengal today is the peculiar beehive she has constructed around herself. This conglomeration comprises virgin Marxists, ultra communists, political opportunists, renegades, NGOs, fundamentalists, right wing and left wing intelligentsia; all fervently anti-CPI (M).

As a matter of fact, blatant hypocrisy, vicious jealousy, megalomania, denigration, intolerance and bigotry - all the typical characteristics are getting detonated on this new platform provided by Mamata Banerjee. The issues of Nandigram, Singur and Rijwanur Rehman were created by the conglomeration for petty electoral gains. Your organization also helped it in all possible manners knowingly or unknowingly.

This assembly is the last hope to 'liberate' the ‘“so-called”’ despaired and strained Bengal populace from thirty-two years of uninterrupted Left Front rule in the elections to be held in 2011 as has been done in different European countries to dislodge Leftist Governments with the help of imperialists and corporate finance capital.

In fact, “so-called” social activists Arundhati Roy, Mahasweta Devi, Medha Patkar, actress Aparna Sen and other intellectuals and human right activists sharing same opinion and boat are bent upon pushing India into a civil war in the name of fighting for the “so-called” cause of the tribals. Their destructive and hideous role during Nandigram-Singur episodes and support to the Maoist slaughterers, rapists and plunderers has emboldened the Maoist terrorists to carry on their criminal and gruesome activities uninterrupted.

These “so-called” intellectuals are very much apprehensive and worried for the safety and security of the perverted Maoist butchers and rapists in India, who have been carrying on their nefarious and criminal inhuman brutalities on the common people ranging from amassing huge wealth, destruction of natural resources, plunder, rape, murder, extortion, blowing up schools, health centres, railway tracks, torture and Kangaroo trial using the indigenous people as pawns and human shields. Out of her utter sympathy and compassion for the Maoist butchers and rapists, social activist Arundhati Roy has initiated a mass petition on 12th October 2009 to the Prime Minister of India urging him to stop offensive against them and their brutalities under the pretext of civil rigthts. She has obtained the signatures of respected Noam Chomsky and other renowned dignitaries within the country and abroad to make the petition more acceptable, significant and weighty in order to glorify and justify the Maoist cruelties and violence particularly on the indigenous people. If Arundhati Roy and other signatories were really interested for the well being of the indigenous people, they would have also petitioned openly to the perverted Maoist butchers in the same manner, style and spirit urging them to desist from wreaking havoc on the indigenous people by using them as pawn and shield for suiting the tainted Maoist political agenda. But it is not so. The one and only one aim and objective of the petition is to push India into civil war and create sympathy for the Maoists and justify, glorify and legitimize their mindless shocking brutalities.

The society demands timely disposal of the dead body of even a creature. But the entire world witnessed with horror how the dead bodies of 4 poor tribal CPI (M) cadres butchered by Maoist-TMC-Congress-SUCI Alliance were kept in open for 5 days without allowing disposal by the Maoist-TMC criminals at Lalgarh in West Bengal. Their relatives were neither allowed to come near nor touch the bodies. The Maoists and TMC workers danced and sang around the bodies in the same manner as is practiced by cannibals. Their brutality and inhumanity surpassed all limits of human tolerance and society.

These “so-called” Indian intellectuals and human right activists had played an important role during Nandigram and Singur episodes to extend moral and logical support to the rainbow alliance of TMC, Congress, Maoists and SUCI under Mamata Banerjee. They had unleashed widespread virulent, venomous, exaggerated and politically motivated campaign throughout the world and organised processions, rallies, meetings, and mass signatures and so on against the mainstream Leftists over the unfortunate death of 14 persons in Nandigram resulting from provoked police firing where as they maintain complete silence over regular murders committed by the Maoists. Many of them had directly or indirectly worked actively for the victory of Maoist and Mamata Banerjee supported Congress-TMC-SUCI candidates in West Bengal in the last Parliamentary elections held in May 2009 making the Nandigram, Singur and Rijwanur Rehaman episodes important election issues.

Despite this, these ‘pseudo’ Indian intellectuals all along shamelessly pretend to be impartial, neutral and non-political.

More than 87% landowners had consented to offer their land for the establishment of an automobile factory at Singur. But it was abandoned due to the political agitation of Mamata Banerjee and her team consisting of opposition political parties, Maoists, some intellectuals, few human right activists and a section of motivated media. Singur had nothing to do with SEZ.

Similarly, in spite of repeated assurances by the Chief Minister of West Bengal that no chemical hub would be set up at Nandigram, Mamata Banerjee and her team had caused the unfortunate incident on 14th March 2007 by way of utter provocation and manipulation resulting in 14 unfortunate deaths.

Had these intellectuals been impartial, unprejudiced and unbiased the incidents of neither Singur nor Nandigram would have taken place.

The Maoist-TMC-Congress-SUCI butchers under the leadership of the Union Railway Minister have murdered brutally hundreds of CPI (M) and other Leftist leaders, cadres and supporters in West Bengal. They have blown up school buildings, health centres, mobile towers, railway lines, railways stations and what not. But these intellectuals and human right activists are maintaining complete silence. They think that only the Maoists are human beings and as such have access to civil rights. Except the Maoists, none in the country can have any human rights and the murder of hundreds of people by Maoists is, therefore, justified and a need for the society. So, they have not yet uttered even a single word to condemn the crimes of the Maoists.

Every murder is unfortunate and condemnable. Had this group of intellectuals and human right activists played an impartial role and stopped lending moral and logical support to the Maoist butchers, the unfortunate deaths at Nandigram and other parts of the country could have been avoided easily. But the fact was that Mamata Banerjee and her rainbow alliance needed some dead bodies for winning the parliamentary elections in West Bengal riding over sympathy wave and the intellectuals and human rights activists presented the same in time to suit her political agenda.

LIST OF INNOCENT PEOPLE MURDERED BY MAOIST-TMC-CONGRESS-SUCI BUTCHERS AND RAPISTS IN WEST BENGAL FROM 01-12-2009 TO 04-01-2010 IS PLACED BELOW.

No. Name of the victim, Address of the victim, Date of murder

1 Ramjan Mallik, Garbeta, Medinipur (W), 23-01-01
2 Tapan Ghosh, Garbeta, Medinipur (W), 08-04-01
3 Shibaram Satpathi, Sarenga, Bankura, 10-04-01
4 Sudhir Singh Sardar, Banspahari, Medinipur (W), 28-11-01
5 Anil Mahato, Shalboni, Medinipur (W), 04-02-02
6 Rampada Majhi, Ranibandh, Bankura, 11-02-02
7 Puntibala Mahato, Shalboni, Medinipur (W), 31-05-02
8 Icchhamati Mahato, Shalboni, Medinipur (W), 31-05-02
9 Priyanka Mahato (4yrs), Shalboni, Medinipur (W), 31-05-02
10 Ajit Ghosh, Goaltore, Medinipur (W), 09-07-02
11 Golap Mallik, Garbeta, Medinipur (W), 24-04-03
12 Baridbaran Mondal, Banspahari, Medinipur (W) 21-10-03
13 Asit Santra, Goaltore, Medinipur (W), 02-03-04
14 Mahendra Mahato, Bandowan, Purulia, 09-07-05
15 Raghunath Murmu, Barikul, Bankura, 09-07-05
16 Bablu Mudi, Barikul, Bankura, 09-07-05
17 Rabindranath Kar, Bandowan, Bankura, 30-12-05
18 Anandamayi Kar, Bandowan, Bankura, 30-12-05
19 Kartik Singh, Lalgarh, Medinipur (W), 04-03-06
20 Gatilal Tudu, Barikul, Bankura, 04-03-06
21 Gumai Murmu, Belpahari, Medinipur (W), 08-03-06
22 Jaladhar Mahato, Belpahari, Medinipur (W), 08-03-06
23 Rabi Das, Belpahari, Medinipur (W), 14-06-06
24 Snehashis Das, Lalgarh, Medinipur (W), 26-05-06
25 Uttam Sardar, Chandpur, Nadia, 19-06-06
26 Swapan Sardar, Chandpur, Nadia, 19-06-06
27 Anil Mahato, Shilda, Medinipur (W), 19-09-06
28 Dinesh Baske, Shilda, Medinipur (W), 19-09-06
29 Sankar Samanta, Nandigram, W. Midnapur, 07-01-07
30 Pailaram Tudu, Banspahari, Medinipur (W), 09-01-07
31 Sunita Mandal, Nandigram, W. Midnapur, 09-02-07
32 Jamini Mandal (Das) , Nandigram, W. Midnapur, 10-03-07
33 Rampada Singh, Belpahari, Medinipur (W), 30-03-07
34 Parikshit Singh, Belpahari, Medinipur (W), 30-03-07
35 Mantu Mandal, Nandigram, W. Midnapur, 04-04-07
36 Dilip Mandal, Nandigram, W. Midnapur, 29-04-07
37 Mohiroah Karan, Nandigram, W. Midnapur, 29-04-07
38 Ram Kamila, Nandigram, W. Midnapur, 05-05-07
39 Sunita Jana, Nandigram, W. Midnapur, 07-05-07
40 Rasmoni Das, Nandigram, W. Midnapur, 08-05-07
41 Manik Mahato, Lalgarh, Medinipur (W), 27-05-07
42 Mahadeb Mandal, Nandigram, W. Midnapur, 24-06-07
43 Harekrishna Chiti, Nandigram, W. Midnapur, 04-07-07
44 Rohit Roy, Lalgarh, Medinipur (W), 10-07-07
45 Bapan Patra, Nandigram, W. Midnapur, 29-07-07
46 Arun Das, Nandigram, W. Midnapur, 04-08-07
47 Manas Mandal, Nandigram, W. Midnapur, 08-10-07
48 Mohan Mandal, Nandigram, W. Midnapur, 08-10-07
49 Mir Khurshed, Nandigram, W. Midnapur, 26-10-07
50 Gostha Das, Nandigram, W. Midnapur, 27-10-07
51 Sunil Bar, Nandigram, W. Midnapur, 27-10-07
52 Bachan Garudas, Nandigram, W. Midnapur, 27-10-07
53 Srimanta Das, Nandigram, W. Midnapur, 30-10-07
54 Gourhari Laya Das, Nandigram, W. Midnapur, 01-11-07
55 Gabinda Singh, Nandigram, W. Midnapur, 01-11-07
56 Bhagirath Karmakar, Barabazar, Purulia, 01-11-07
57 Tapan Manna, Nandigram, W. Midnapur, 03-11-07
58 Nirapada Ghanta, Nandigram, W. Midnapur, 06-11-07
59 Tushar Shaw, Nandigram, W. Midnapur, 06-11-07
60 Sankar Maiti, Nandigram, W. Midnapur, 06-11-07
61 Chanchal Middya, Nandigram, W. Midnapur, 07-11-07
62 Sufal Mandi, Purulia, Purulia, 20-11-07
63 Govind Singh, Banspahari, Medinipur (W), 06-12-07
64 Sisir Chatterjee, Mangalkote, Burdwan, 01-01-08
65 Pahalan Kumar, Balarampur, Purulia, 01-01-08
66 Ramprasad Mondal, Chapra, Nadia, 02-01-08
67 Mangal Mahato, Banspahari, Medinipur (W), 15-02-08
68 Karam Chand Singh, Belpahari, 22-02-08
69 Subhash Mahato, Belpahari, Medinipur (W), 29-02-08
70 Budhadeb Pathak, Lalgarh, Medinipur (W), 09-03-08
71 Mukul Tiwari, Shalboni, Medinipur (W), 13-04-08
72 Jugol Murmu, Shalboni, Medinipur (W), 13-04-08
73 Nabakumar Murmu, Shalboni, Medinipur (W), 13-04-08
74 Kshetrapal Majhi, Arsha, Purulia, 19-04-08
75 Sridam Das, Khoirashole, Birbhum, 22-04-08
76 Ganapati Bhadra, Bandowan, Purulia, 04-05-08
77 Debraj Hembram, Balarampur, Purulia, 05-05-08
78 Biswanath Mandi, Goaltore, Medinipur (W), 15-06-08
79 Niranjan Mondal, Nandigram, Medinipur (E), 06-08-08
80 Dulal Garu Das, Garupara, Medinipur (E), 07-08-08
81 Firoj Mondal, Chakdah, Nadia, 01-09-08
82 Satyanarayan Ganguli, Dubrajpur, Birbhum, 05-09-08
83 Sunil Halsana, Chakdah, Nadia, 16-09-08
84 Mansoor Alam, Goalpokhar, Dinajpur (N), 17-09-08
85 Nandalal Mistri, Rajnagar, Birbhum, 22-09-08
86 Amar Ghugu, Patrasayar, Bankura, 04-10-08
87 Prodyut Maiti (Naru), Khejuri, Midnapur (E), 10-10-08
88 Mahidul Seikh, Harirampur, Dinajpur (S), 14-10-08
89 Alauddin Molla, Haroa, 24, Parganas (N), 20-10-08
90 Kutub Mondal, Galsi, Burdwan, 21-10-08
91 Satyajit Mondal, Karanjora, Bankura, 22-10-08
92 Debi Prasad Singh, Ausgram, Burdwan, 24-10-08
93 Shankar Rauth, Canning, 24, Parganas (S), 27-10-08
94 Indrajit Muda, Banspahari, Midnapur (W), 31-10-08
95 Seikh Sanai, Khoirashole, Birbhum, 04-11-08
96 Mrinal Sarkar, Nakasipara, Nadia, 05-11-08
97 Namita Sarkar, Nakasipara, Nadia, 05-11-08
98 Mazid Seikh, Baharampur, Murshidabad, 12-11-08
99 Panu Bouri, Patrasayar, Bankura, 14-11-08
100 Sheetkantha Mondal, Kandi, Murshidabad, 21-11-08
101 Mostaque Ahmad, Bolepur, Birbhum, 21-11-08
102 Qurban Seikh, Mayureswar, Birbhum, 11-12-08
103 Gaja Mohammad, Islampur, Dinajpur (N), 13-12-08
104 Uttam Roy, Jangipara, Hooghly, 16-12-08
105 Arshad Ali, Dalkhola, Dinajpur (N), 23-12-08
106 Dilip Manna, Purshura, Hooghly, 23-12-08
107 Dasrathi Ghosh, Bhatar, Burdwan, 12-01-09
108 Shamsur Alam Mallick, Indas, Bankura, 16-01-09
109 Motibur Rahaman, Kushmundi, Dinajpur (S), 26-01-09
110 Sujit Dasgupta, Dumdum, 24, Parganas (N), 27-01-09
111 Sambhu Dasgupta, Dumdum, 24, Parganas (N), 27-01-09
112 Nandalal Pal, Lalgarh, Midnapur (W), 01-02-09
113 Haradhan Majhi, Balarampur, Purulia, 03-02-09
114 Biswanath Digar, Ranibandh, Bankura, 08-02-09
115 Sujit Ponda, Lalgarh, Midnapur (W), 13-02-09
116 Nurul Islam Dewan, Raina, Burdwan, 22-02-09
117 Jharna Mandi, Dhaniakhali, Hooghly, 26-02-09
118 Sumana Mandi, Dhaniakhali, Hooghly, 26-02-09
119 Tapas Mondal, Naihati, 24, Parganas (N), 03-03-09
120 Saiyad Ali Bhuiyan, Jaipur, Bankura, 11-03-09
121 Subol Kajli, Khejuri, Midnapur (E), 14-03-09
122 Subodh Barik, Mugberia, Midnapur (E), 15-03-09
123 Ansar Ali, Gangarampur, Dinajpur (S), 17-03-09
124 Himadri Patra, Boga, Midnapur (E), 17-03-09
125 Gopal Mondal, Beharampur, Murshidabad, 18-03-09
126 Soharab Ali Dewan, Raina, Burdwan, 18-03-09
127 Durga Deshwal, Bhulabheda, Midnapur (W), 18-03-09
128 Santosh Mahato, Bhulabheda, Midnapur (W), 18-03-09
129 Bijay Shaw, Titagarh, 24, Parganas (N), 18-03-09
130 Kanai Kumar, Arsha, Purulia, 28-03-09
131 Ganesh Das, Bhagwanpur, Midnapur (E), 28-03-09
132 Ashim Mondal, Bahulabheda, Midnapur (W), 10-04-09
133 Hambir Mandi, Shalboni, Midnapur (W), 21-04-09
134 Shakti Sen, Shalboni, Midnapur (W), 21-04-09
135 Gopinath Murmu, Lalgarh, Midnapur (W), 22-04-09
136 Baikunth Mahato, Supurdihgram, Purulia, 23-04-09
137 Bibhuti Singh Sardar, SD Gram, Purulia , 23-04-09
138 Bhaben Dig, Haripal, Hooghly, 27-04-09
139 Manowar Hossain Jamadar, Amta, Howrah, 07-05-09
140 Kashinath Mondal, Jangipur, Murshidabad, 07-05-09
141 Chandu Dolui, Bagnan, Howrah, 08-05-09
142 Seikh Saidul, Bagnan, Howrah, 08-05-09
143 Seikh Babua, Bagnan, Howrah, 08-05-09
144 Seikh Aksar, Nandigram, Midnapur (E), 09-05-09
145 Abdullah Khan, Nandigram, Midnapur (E), 09-05-09
146 Mahiuddin Khan, Tamluk, Midnapur (E), 10-05-09
147 Joynal Molla, Canning, 24, Parganas (S), 13-05-09
148 Manu Singh, Bandowan, Purulia, 15-05-09
149 Momtaj Seikh, Raninagar, Murshidabad, 16-05-09
150 Arvind Mondal, Chari Antapur, Maldah, 17-05-09
151 Bibek Barman, Goksadanga, Coochbihar, 19-05-09
152 Kartik Mohaladar, Ratua, Maldah, 22-05-09
153 Dinesh Mahato, Balarmpur, Purulia, 23-05-09
154 Manoranjan Naskar, Bishnpur, 24, Pgs. (S), 23-05-09
155 Santosh Barman, Nandigram, Midnapur (E), 25-05-09
156 Bhondulal Munda, Jhalda, Purulia,, 25-05-09
157 Apurba Ghosh, Krishnanagar, Nadia, 28-05-09
158 Nuruddin Seikh, Rampurhat, Birbhum, 31-05-09
159 Sayantika Rakhit, BN Nagar, Midnapur (E), 01-06-09
160 Khalek Molla, Haroa, 24, Parganas (N), 02-06-09
161 Dinesh Deb Singh, GR Pur, Dinajpur (S), 06-06-09
162 Govind Samanta, Panshkura, Midnapur (E), 06-06-09
163 Mamoni Kishku, Binpur, Midnapur (W), 06-06-09
164 Kinkar Dolui, Panchla, Howrah, 08-06-09
165 Salku Soren, Lalgarh, Midnapur (W), 11-06-09
166 Sitabur Seikh, Lalgola, Murshidabad, 11-06-09
167 Ikramul Haque, Beharampur, Murshidabad, 12-06-09
168 Shankar Tudu, Belpahari, Midnapur (W), 13-06-09
169 Asit Samanta, Lalgarh, Midnapur (W), 13-06-09
170 Naru Samanta, Lalgarh, Midnapur (W), 13-06-09
171 Prabir Mahato, Lalgarh, Midnapur (W), 13-06-09
172 Keshab Manna, Shalboni, Midnapur (W), 14-06-09
173 Dhiraj Manna, Shalboni, Midnapur (W), 14-06-09
174 Sanjay Mahato, Shalboni, Midnapur (W), 14-06-09
175 Pabitra Das, Nandigram, Midnapur (E), 14-06-09
176 Debabrata Soren, Shalboni, Midnapur (W), 14-06-09
177 Mohan Singh, Shalboni, Midnapur (W), 14-06-09
178 Tuntuni Jana, Amedabad, Midnapur (E), 14-06-09
179 Falguni Mukherjee, Mangalkote, Burdwan, 15-06-09
180 Sunil Das, Shalboni, Midnapur (W), 16-06-09
181 Tapan Das, Shalboni, Midnapur (W), 16-06-09
182 Sanjay Pratihar, Lalgarh, Midnapur (W), 16-06-09
183 Niladri Mahato, Lodashuli, Midnapur (W), 17-06-09
184 Anil Mahato, Lodashuli, Midnapur (W), 17-06-09
185 Abhijit Mahato, Lodashuli, Midnapur (W), 17-06-09
186 Badal Chandra Ahir, Goaltore, Midnapur (W), 18-06-09
187 Sisir Mahato, Lalgarh, Midnapur (W), 18-06-09
188 Dubraj Soren, Goaltore, Midnapur (W), 18-06-09
189 Dasarath Soren, Goaltore, Midnapur (W), 18-06-09
190 Chaitnya Soren, Goaltore, Midnapur (W), 18-06-09
191 Keshav Das, Nandigram, Midnapur (W), 19-06-09
192 Siraj Khan, Itaru, Galsi, Burdwan, 21-06-09
193 Ajay Rauth, Haldia, Midnapur (E), 21-06-09
194 Budheswar Mahato, Lalgarh, Midnapur (W), 21-06-09
195 Pranesh Ghosh, Lalgarh, Midnapur (W), 21-06-09
196 Naba Kumar Murmu, Lalgarh, Midnapur (W), 26-06-09
197 Kishore Tiwari, Lalgarh, Midnapur (W), 26-06-09
198 Jugol Murmu, Lalgarh, Midnapur (W), 26-06-09
199 Moloy Mahato, Lalgarh, Midnapur (W), 05-07-09
200 Motilal Mahato, Lalgarh, Midnapur (W), 05-07-09
201 Pinki Khatun (8 yrs), Domkol, Murshidabad, 09-07-09
202 Barendranath Mahato, Lalgarh, Medinipur (W 10-07-09
203 Gurucharan Mahato, Lalgarh, West Dinajpur, 11-07-09
204 Abijit Mondal (11 years), Uluberia, Howrah, 13-07-09
205 Swapan Deb Singh, Shalboni, Midnapur (W), 14-07-09
206 Tarani Singh, Shalboni, Midnapur (W), 14-07-09
207 Gangadhar Mahato, Barabazar, Purulia, 15-07-09
208 Jaladhar Mahato, Jhargam, Purulia, 18-07-09
209 Ashok Ghosh, Goaltore, Midnapur (W), 18-07-09
210 Fagu Baske, Belpahari, Midnapur (W), 22-07-09
211 Arghya Samanta, Raina, Burdwan, 27-07-09
212 Ananda Das, Rajganj, Jalpaiguri, 28-07-09
213 Sagar Masant, Goaltore, Midnapur (W), 30-07-09
214 Ashok Mahato, Lalgarh, Midnapur (W), 31-07-09
215 Brahmodeo Singh, Lalgarh, Midnapur (W), 31-07-09
216 Motilal Mahato, Lalgarh, Midnapur (W), 31-07-09
217 Moloy Mahato, Lalgarh, Midnapur (W), 31-07-09
218 Nirmal Mahato, Bhulabheda, Midnapur (W), 02-08-09
219 Gurucharan Tudu, Lalgarh, Midnapur (W), 03-08-09
220 Shankar D. Adhikari, Lalgarh, Midnapur (W), 05-08-09
221 Gunadhar Singh, Bhulabheda, Midnapur (W), 05-08-09
222 Shaktipada Murmu, Lalgarh, Midnapur (W), 06-08-09
223 Ashim Soren, Lalgarh, Midnapur (W), 06-08-09
224 Budhu Hansda, Lalgarh, Midnapur (W), 06-08-09
225 Ramkrishna Duley, Sarenga, Bankura, 15-08-09
226 Madar Ali Molla, Canning, 24, Parganas (S), 17-08-09
227 Samrendranath Konai, Madgram, Birbhum, 18-08-09
228 Anirul Islam, Rajarhat, 24, Parganas (N), 23-08-09
229 Mangal Soren, Binpur, Midnapur (W), 29-08-09
230 Laxmikanta Kumar, Sindurpur, Purulia, 29-08-09
231 Madan Mondal, Garulia, North 24, Parganas, 29-08-09
232 Bharat Hembram, Balarampur, Purulia, 30-08-09
233 Sukhdeo Mahato, Bhramarmara, Midnapur (W), 31-08-09
234 Debi Prasad Hansda, Balarampur, Purulia, 31-08-09
235 Abu Ali Mondal, Baruipur, 24, Parganas (S), 03-09-09
236 Hashem Mondal, Baruipur, 24, Parganas (S), 03-09-09
237 Mirazul Seikh, Beldanga, Murshidabad, 04-09-09
238 Azmat Seikh, Beldanga, Murshidabad, 04-09-09
239 Ketabul Seikh, Kaliachak, Maldah, 04-09-09
240 Apu Singh, Lalgarh, Midnapur (W), 06-09-09
241 Rajib Singh, Lalgarh, Midnapur (W), 06-09-09
242 Satish Singh Sardar, Lalgarh, Midnapur (W), 06-09-09
243 Sasanka Sekhar Roy, Lalgarh, Midnapur (W), 06-09-09
244 Shyam Chalak, Lalgarh, Midnapur (W), 07-09-09
245 Ramdas Murmu, Sarenga, Bankura, 08-09-09
246 Baneswar Murmu, Sarenga, Bankura, 08-09-09
247 Abhiram Das, Nanur, Birbhum, 08-09-09
248 Krishna Kundu, Sarenga, Bankura, 10-09-09
249 Bakul Seikh, Lalgola, Murshidabad, 11-09-09
250 Ramen Ghosh, Lalgola, Murshidabad, 12-09-09
251 Seikh Nazrul, Lalgarh, Midnapur (W), 13-09-09
252 Kartik Mahato, Lalgarh, Midnapur (W), 13-09-09
253 Sambhu Mahato, Lalgarh, Midnapur (W), 13-09-09
254 Ajoy Patra, Shalboni, Medinipur (W), 16-09-09
255 Dilip Dhara, Jadavpur, Kolkata, 17-09-09
256 Zikaria Seikh, Baryan, Murshidabad, 20-09-09
257 Manik Mandi, Lalgarh, Medinipur (W), 20-09-09
258 Budheswar Mandi, Lalgarh, Midnapur (W), 20-09-09
259 Bagan Mandi, Lalgarh, Midnapur (W), 20-09-09
260 Nimai Bisui, Lalgarh, Midnapur (W), 24-09-09
261 Samir Singha Mahapatra, Midnapur (W), 24-09-09
262 Rafique Molla, Patharpratima, 24, Parganas (S), 25-09-09
263 Susanta Dhara, Ausgram, Burdwan, 27-09-09
264 Radhanath Mahato, Shalboni, Midnapur (W), 30-09-09
265 Anadi Mahato, Shalboni, Midnapur (W), 30-09-09
266 Bhakti Mahato, Shalboni, Midnapur (W), 30-09-09
267 Barun Pratihar, Lalgarh, Midnapur (W), 01-10-09
268 Amalendu Patra, Lalgarh, Midnapur (W), 02-10-09
269 Panchanan Tudu, Lalgarh, Midnapur (W), 02-10-09
270 Lakhman Sarkar, Ausgram, Burdwan, 05-10-09
271 Sasadhar Mahato, Lalgarh, Midnapur (W), 08-10-09
272 Seikh Hashibul, Khanakul, Hooghly, 09-10-09
273 Kanai Murmu, Binpur, Midnapur (W), 13-10-09
274 Mantu Mudi, Belpahari, W. Midnapur, 18-10-09
275 Ratan Mudi, Belpahari, W. Midnapur, 18-10-09
276 Shital Hembram, Binpur, Midnapur (W), 19-10-09
277 Dibakar Bhattacharjee, Sankrail, W. Midnapur, 20-10-09
278 Swapan Roy, Sankrail, W. Midnapur, 20-10-09
279 Basanta Pakhira, Khanakul, Hooghly, 24-10-09
280 Pratap Nayek, Binpur, W. Midnapur, 26-10-09
281 Jayfal Mondal, Suti, Murshidabad, 27-10-09
282 Dhajen Mondal, Murshidabad, 27-10-09
283 Tapan Mudi, Belpahari, W. Midnapur, 29-10-09
284 Dilip Mahato, Belpahari, W Midnapur, 29-10-09
285 Tushar Ghosh, Bongaon, N. 24 Parganas, 31-10-09
286 Madhab Mudi, Belpahari, W. Midnapur, 31-10-09
287 Anil Mahato, Binpur, W. Midnapur, 01-11-09
288 Saifunissa Bibi, Khanakul, Hooghly, 04-11-09
289 Joyram Hansda, Binpur, W. Midnapur, 07-11-09
290 Manoranjan Mahali, Binpur, W. Midnapur, 07-11-09
291 Lakshmi Das, Binpur, W. Midnapur, 07-11-09
292 Naba Kumar Singh, Binpur, W. Midnapur, 08-11-09
293 Naresh Thapa, Jamboni, W. Midnapur, 08-11-09
294 Binod Tamang, Jamboni, W. Midnapur, 08-11-09
295 Bhaktabahadur Limbu, Jamboni, W. Midnapur, 8-11-09
296 Dhanbahadur Viswakarma, Jamboni, W. Midnapur, 8-11-09
297 Ishaq Seikh, Kaliachak, Maldah, 11-11-2009
298 Sashticharan Dutta, Belpahari, W. Midnapore, 15-11-2009
299 Ajit Mahato, Jhargram, W. Midnapore, 16-11-2009
300 Khudiram Mudi, W. Midnapore, 16-11-2009
301 Totan Das, Shalboni, W. Midnapore, 18-11-2009
302 Samiran Das, Shalboni, W. Midnapore, 18-11-2009
303 Jaganath Mahato, Shalboni, W. Midnapore, 19-11-2009
304 Bhanguram Hansda, Kotwali, W. Midnapore, 19-11-2009
305 Tapan Mahato, Shalboni, W. Midnapore, 23-11-2009
306 Ashok Kotal, Shalboni, W. Midnapore, 23-11-2009
307 Madan Ghosh, Binpur, W. Midnapore, 24-11-2009
308 Subimal Mali, Arsha, Purulia, 26-11-2009
309 Srikanta Banerjee, Binpur, W. Midnapore, 27-11-2009
310 Alok Mondal, Binpur, W. Midnapur, 27-11-2009
311 Karuna Mahato, Shalboni, W. Midnapur, 27-11-2009
312 Braja Bikash Mahato, Binpur, W. Midnapur, 27-11-2009
313 Bomkesh Giri, Binpur, W. Midnapur, 27-11-2009
314 Rassel Seikh, Kaliachak, Maldah, 28-11-2009
315 Dhanapati Murmu, Shalboni, W. Midnapur, 28-11-2009
316 Manowara Bibi, Bishnpur, 24, Parganas (S), 02-12-09
317 Animesh Mitra, Bongaon, 24, Parganas (N), 02-12-09
318 Nimai Singh, Belpahari, W. Midnapur, 03-12-09
319 Koni Singh, Belpahari, W. Midnapur, 03-12-09
320 Ramchandra Lay, Arsha, Purulia, 04-12-09
321 Bholanath Khutia, Moyna, East Midnapur, 05-12-09
322 Gurupada Mondal, Moyna, East Midnapur, 05-12-09
323 Sanatan Pratihar, Lalgarh, W. Midnapur, 06-12-2009
324 Subol Mahato, Belpahari, West Midnapur, 08-12-2009
325 Asit Mondal, Bandowan, Purulia, 09-12-2009
326 Brahspati Mahato, Jhargram, West Midnapur, 09-12-2009
327 Manik Mahato, Jhargram, West Midnapur, 09-12-2009
328 Bijoy Mahato, Jhargram, West Midnapur, 09-12-2009
329 Robi Mahato, Shalboni, West Midnapur, 09-12-2009
330 Panchanan Mahato, Shalboni, W. Midnapur, 11-12-09
331 Tilak Tudu, Shalboni, W. Midnapur, 11-12-09
332 Dinabandhu Soren, Lalgarh, W. Midnapur, 12-12-09
333 Akshay Mondqal, Ramnagar, E. Midnapur, 17-12-09
334 Anil Chalak, Shalboni, W. Midnapur, 17-12-09
335 Dayal Chalak, Shalboni, W. Midnapur, 17-12-09
336 Amal Patra, Shalboni, W. Midnapur, 17-12-09
337 Shridam Hembram, Belpahari, W. Midnapur, 18-12-09
338 Nishikanta Bera, Midnapur Sadar, E. Midnapur, 18-12-09
339 Sisir Jana, Dharampur, W. Midnapur, 18-12-09
340 Gopal Mahato, Jhargram, W. Midnapur, 19-12-09
341 Khagen Mahato, Jhargram, W. Midnapur, 19-12-09
342 Mossaraf Khan. Canning, 24, Parganas (S), 20-12-09
343 Sadhan Mahato, Jhargram, W. Midnapur, 22-12-09
344 Jiarul Haque Molla, Bhangad, 24, Pgs (S), 22-12-09
345 Sadek Seikh, Hariharpara, Murshidabad, 23-12-09
346 Sariful Seikh, Hariharpara, Murshidabad, 23-12-09
347 Prabir Dandapat, Gopiballavpur, W. Midnapur, 23-12-0
348 Hablu Patra, Lalgarh, W. Midnapur, 23-12-09
349 Sadhan Mahato, Lalgarh, W. Midnapur, 23-12-09
350 Biswanath Murmu, Belpahari, W. Midnapur, 24-12-09
351 Rameswar Murmu, Ranibandh, Bankura, 26-12-09
352 Abdul Hai, Rampurhat, Birbhum, 28-12-09
353 Kalipada Hembram, Ranibandh, Bankura, 30-12-09
354 Anand Singh, Belpahari, W. Midnapur, 31-12-09
355 Kunaram Singh, Belpahari, W. Midnapur, 31-12-09
356 Bhagbat Singh, Nayagram, W. Midnapur, 01-01-10
357 Rabindra Mondal, Ramnagar, E. Midnapur, 01-01-10
358 Anath Singh, Belpahari, W. Midnapur, 03-01-10
359 Hiteswar Singh, Belpahari, W. Midnapur, 03-01-10
360 Jhantu Patra, Lalgarh, W. Midnapur, 03-01-10
361 Hekim Munda, Shalboni, W. Midnapur, 03-01-10
362 Bapi Bakli, Shalboni, W. Midnapur, 03-01-10
363 Panchanan Mondal, Baharampur, Murshidabad, 04-01-10
364 Haren Baske, Ranibandh, Purulia, 07-01-10
365 Sk. Manjur Ali, Jungalmahal, 08-01-10 (*)
366 Nirmal Nayek, Jungalmahal, 08-01-10 (*)
367 Dhonu Rajaki, Bandowan, Purulia, 10-01-10
368 Biswanath Dutta, Simlapol, Bankura, 10-01-10
369 Dinesh Haldar, Canning, 24, Parganas, 11-01-10
370 Biswanath Gayen, Canning, 24, Parganas, 11-01-10
371 Khayrul Jamadar, Canning, 24, Parganas, 11-01-10
372 Selim Jamdadar, Canning, 24, Parganas, 11-01-10
373 Gobinda Pradhan, Mathurapur, 24, Parganas, 13-01-10
374 Uttam Banik, Palta, North 24, Parganas, 15-01-10
375 Tarashankar Sarkar, Khanpur, S. Dinajpur, 15-01-10
376 Lina Khatoon (12 Yrs), Islampur, N. Dinajpur, 16-01-10
377 Dipanwita Jana, Nandigram, E. Midnapur, 22-01-10
378 Mahadeb Bouri, Dubrajpur, Birbhum, 22-01-10
379 Pratham Bouri, Dubrajpur, Birbhum, 22-01-10
380 Robi Das, Kalyani, Nadia, 24-01-10
381 Guhiram Singh, Nayagram, W. Midnapur, 25-01-10
382 Bechuram Adak, Tarakeswar, Hooghly, 25-01-10
383 Sanjay Ghosh, Barikul, Bankura, 26-01-10
384 Ranjit Hembram, Sarenga, Bankura, 27-01-10
385 Jaganath Mahato, Shalboni, W. Midnapur, 30-01-10
386 Fazlool Karim, Suri, Birbhum, 30-01-10
387 Jamal Seikh, Suri, Birbhum, 30-01-10
388 Fagu Seikh, Suri, Birbhum, 30-01-10
389 Atul Singh Sardar, Belpahari, W. Midnapur, 01-02-10
390 Khuran Seikh, Kaliachak, Maldah, 04-02-10
391 Basudeb Das, Khairasole, Birbhum, 04-02-10
392 Baren Singh, Belpahari, W. Dinajpur, 11-02-10
393 Saidul Mallick, Beldanga, Murshidabad, 12-02-10
394 Kalo Seikh, Nanoor, Birbhum, 14-02-10
395 Basudeb Mete, Nanoor, Birbhum, 14-02-10
396 Ajoy Thapa, Shilda, W. Midnapur, 15-02-10
397 Gogan Pradhan, Shilda, W. Midnapur, 15-02-10
398 Bihan Kachari, Shilda, W. Midnapur, 15-02-10
399 Prem Singh Bhutia, Shilda, W. Midnapur, 15-02-10
400 Mikmar Tamang, Shilda, W. Midnapur, 15-02-10
401 Arun Singh Thakuri, Shilda, W. Midnapur, 15-02-10
402 Surya Bahadur Thapa, Shilda, W. Midnapur, 15-02-10
403 Jivan Chetri, Shilda, W. Midnapur, 15-02-10
404 Banin Chandra Dhimari, Shilda, W. Midnapur, 15-02-10
405 Arindra Kumar Rava, Shilda, W. Midnapur, 15-02-10
406 Kanteswar Basumatari, Shilda, W. Midnapur, 15-02-10
407 Monal Chetri, Shilda, W. Midnapur, 15-02-10
408 Suresh Rai, Shilda, W. Midnapur, 15-02-10
409 Nimte Sherpa, Shilda, W. Midnapur, 15-02-10
410 Pradip Pradhan, Shilda, W. Midnapur, 15-02-10
411 Madhukar Subba, Shilda, W. Midnapur, 15-02-10
412 Shanti Kumar Rai, Shilda, W. Midnapur, 15-02-10
413 Dambar Bahadur Chetri, Shilda, W. Midnapur, 15-02-10
414 Chandra Chetri, Shilda, W. Midnapur, 15-02-10
415 Gopal Krishna Chetri, Shilda, W. Midnapur, 15-02-10
416 Biman Rai, Shilda, W. Midnapur, 15-02-10
417 Doulat Rai, Shilda, W. Midnapur, 15-02-10
418 Premtosh Lepcha, Shilda, W. Midnapur, 15-02-10
419 Ram Bahadur Thapa, Shilda, W. Midnapur, 15-02-10
420 Nakul Singh, Bandowan, Purulia, 18-02-10
421 Baneswar Singh, Bandowan, Purulia, 18-02-10
422 Karani Mahato, Bandowan, Purulia, 18-02-10
423 Robi Lochan Mitra, Sarenga, Bankura, 25-02-10

Most of the Maoist victims are teachers, grocers, daily wage earners, farmers, government employees, police & soldiers, labourers, students, rickshaw pullers, hawkers and people belonging to other weaker sections of the society.

It is also a fact that most of the victims belong to indigenous people comprising Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes, Muslims and other weaker sections of the society.

Apart from this, 65 police personnel 1 doctor, 1 nurse, 4 government employees on duty were also killed by Maoists.

There is no denying the fact that PUCL, APDR and other similar “so-called” human right organizations have been fully supporting the Maoist ideology and brutalities on different pretexts to destabilize the country.

Under the circumstances, I would request you to kindly look into the matter seriously and ensure that this procession of deaths in India is stopped immediately in the interest of human rights of all irrespective of political affiliation, caste, creed and religion.

Thanking you while awaiting prompt action.

Again with regards,

Yours faithfully,
R. Vijayan

Copy forwarded to respected Noam Chomsky for his information

DRAMATIST SHAOLI MITRA KEEPS SILENCE TO SUPPORT THE MASSACRE OF 24 JAWANS AT SHILDA IN WEST BENGAL BY MAOIST BUTCHERS ON 15-02-2010

A few social and political activists and intellectuals such as Arundhati Roy, Mamata Banerjee, Medha Patkar, Mahasweta Devi, Dr. Pushkar Raj, film actress Aparna Sen, Shaoli Mitra, Subhaprasanna Bhattachajree, Jogen Chowdhury, Sujat Bhadra, Bibhas Chakraborty and others, day in and day out, always speak for the safety of the perverted Maoist butchers, extortionists and rapists and champion their cause. They have been trying to raise support and a respectable space for them on different manufactures premises.

They also try to create sympathy for them in all possible ways and manners on this or that pretext. But they never use a single word to condemn the brutalities and perversions of their beloved Maoist insane terrorist brethren.

The details of EFR Jawans killed by the perverted Maoist cold blooded murderers at Shilda Camp in West Midnapur District on 15-02-2010 are placed below.

1 Ajoy Thapa, P.S. Maligarh, Darjeeling
2 Gogan Pradhan, P.S. Kharagpur Local, W. Midnapur
3 Bihan Kachari, Salua, W. Midnapur
4 Prem Siring Bhutia, P.S. Kalimpong, Darjeeling
5 Mikmar Tamang, PS Sukhiapokhari, Darjeeling
6 Arun Singh Thakuri, Salua, Dist. W. Midnapur
7 Surya Bahadur Thapa, PS Hijli, W. Midnapur
8 Jiban Chetri, Midnapur Town, W. Midnapur
9 Banin Chandra Dhimari, PS Golpara, Assam
10 Arindra Kumar Rava, Gopalpur, Assam
11 Kanteswar Basumatari, Guwhati, Assam
12 Monal Chetri, Ghum, Dist. Darjeeling
13 Suresh Rai, Mirik, Darjeeling
14 Nimte Sherpa, Pulbazar, Darjeeling
15 Pradip Pradhan, Sukiapokhari, Darjeeling
16 Madhukar Subba, Kalimpong, Darjeeling
17 Shati Kumar Rai, Gorubathan, Darjeeling
18 Dambar Bahadur Chetri, Kalimpong, Darjeeling
19 Subhas Chetri, Kotwali, Jalpaiguri
20 Biman Rai, Jorebunglow, Darjeeling
21 Gopal Krishna Chetri, Malhati, Jalpaiguri
22 Doulat Rai, Ghalibari, Darjeeling
23 Premtas Lepcha, Kalimpong, Darjeeling
24 Ram Bahadur Thapa, Salua, W. Midnapur

Those who provide a shield to the Maoist cold-blooded murderers should also be held as much responsible for the killings as are the Maoists.

Both are two faces of the same coin and therefore must be dealt with an iron hand.

The nation should be cautious of the diabolical aims and objectives of these agents of the perverted Maoists.

"THE STATESMAN" TURNS INTO A POLITICAL TOOL OF MAOIST-TMC-CONGRESS-SUCI RAINBOW ALLIANCE UNDER MAMATA BANERJEE

Shri Debabrata Bandyopadhyay is a trusted Advisor to the eccentric and obstructionist Trinamul Congress Supremo Mamata Banerjee. He is also a former Secretary of Revenue and erstwhile Secretary of Rural Development in the Government of India.

In a recent piece titled, "Citizens Beware! Killer Convicts at Large!" in the Mainstream magazine dated December 4-10, 2009 he has thrown mud on CPI (M) functionaries by building a monument of falsehood about "conviction", "release on parole" and "destruction of records".

In doing so and by using expressions such as "black mamba", "killer convicts", "nasty killer" to describe a serving and elected minister and other public functionaries, the author only further sullies his already discredited image.

What is striking is the absolute lack of editorial due diligence in publishing this malicious piece written by the former bureaucrat. Any editor worth her/his salt would have taken pains to check the veracity of the claims as well as been tempted to use editorial standards to vet some of the abominable language used. But alas, so consumed is the editor in buying the spurious monument of lies, there is none of that necessary editorial work.

Bandyopadhyay's entire article is a pack of lies, wrapped in a monument of malice intended to deliberately attack and demonize serving ministers and senior leaders of the ruling Communist Party of India (Marxist).

The context that provides the author to make such a willful character assassination and deliberate falsification of facts is the ‘Sainbari’ incident on 17th March 1970, where two brothers - sympathisers of the Congress party named Moloy Sain and Pronob Sain were killed.

These murders were made the pretext to falsely implicate the entire leadership of the CPI (M) in Burdwan district. It must be noted that this was done when West Bengal was under President's rule and the Congress party was going all out to target the CPI (M) and its cadres.

The argument of Bandyopadhyay's article is that:

1. 50/60 armed hooligans under the leadership of “Benoy Konar” attacked the residence of Sains in Burdwan with “foul mood” and murdered two Sain brothers named Moloy Sain and Pronob Sain.

2. 17 of the miscreants were responsible for the murder of the Sain brothers.

3. The author does not care to mention their names.

4. Eight of them, were "convicted" and life imprisonment was imposed upon them by the District and Sessions Judge of Burdwan in 1971.

5. Of the eight thus convicted- he names Benoy Konar (who is current Central Committee member of the CPI [M]), Politburo Member and West Bengal industries minister Nirupam Sen, Manik Roy (mentioned as "absconding"), Amal Haldar and Paltoo Bandyopadhyay.

6. The "convicts went on appeal before the Calcutta High Court twice.

7. On both occasions their appeal was rejected.

8. The convicts did not "curiously" prefer to appeal before the Supreme Court and instead "waited for an opportunity to get them out of the prison by foul means".

9. Later, when the CPI (M) came to power, "all the convicts of the Sain murder case were released on “unconditional and unlimited parole”.

10. The "records of the case" were "pilfered" from the "archives of the Calcutta High Court through their [the CPI (M)'s] committed members of the "Coordination Committee" among the employees of the High Court" and were destroyed.

11. The Registrar General, Calcutta High Court had "shockingly" reported to the Supreme Court that the High Court had no paper relating to the Sainbari case.

12. The "convicts" have been "enjoying unrestricted and unconditional parole for the last 32 years".

13. One Joydeep Mukherjee has filed a writ petition before the Supreme Court to find out how the "convicts" have been "enjoying unrestricted and unconditional parole for the last 32 years".

Thus framing his case for the article's headline that "killer convicts are at large", Bandyopadhyay then goes on to construct an elaborate pack of cards bringing the Singur and Nandigram "incidents" into the picture as he makes scurrilous after scandalous claim about the persons in question.

FACTS OF THE CASE AND ORDER

1. The 2nd United Front Government led by Ajoy Mukhopadhyay was dismissed by Governor Dharam Veera on 16-03-1970.

2. A 24-Hour Bangla Bandh was called by the CPI (M) and other Left Parties on the next day 17-03-1970.

3. In each and every locality in West Bengal the “Bandh” was being observed peacefully and the cadres of Leftist Parties took out processions and organized mass meetings against the dismissal of the State Government.

4. A similar peaceful procession was taken out in at Talmaruin area of Burdwan Town on that day by CPI (M) workers.

5. It was attacked by antisocial elements of Congress Party with bombs, lethal weapons and as a result one Gourhari Dey was injured seriously.

6. In the clash followed, 2 Sain brothers named Moloy Sain and Pronab Sain and one private tutor were killed.

7. At 12:30 PM on the same day, one Dilip Kumar Bhattacharya s/o Bomkesh Bhattacharjee of Ahiritola Lane, P.S. & Dist. Burdwan lodged an FIR with the Burdwan Police Station. The FIR was drafted by the District Congress President Nurul Islam in the Congress Party Office in consultation with Panchu Gopal Mukherjee, S.P. of Burdwan, Shankari Chatterjee, Officer-in-Charge, Burdwan Police Station and Rabindranath Ghosh, S.I. of Burdwan Police Station.

All the above three police officers had taken a pledge to wipe out CPI (M) from Burdwan District. Bijoyesh Ganguly was mentioned as witness.

8. The manufactured FIR mentioned clearly the following:

a. A peaceful ‘Bandh’ was being observed at the call of a political party but its armed cadres were giving provocative slogans.

b. At about 8-00 am an armed procession of about 1500/2000 people were proceeding through Pratapeswar-Shibtola in the town where the residence of Sain brothers was situated.

c. The processionists broke open the residence of the Sain Brothers, set it to fire and in the ensuing clash two Sain Brothers named Moloy Sain, Pronob Sain and family private tutor Jiten Roy were killed.

9. On the basis of the said FIR the Burdwan Police Station started P.S Case no 50 dt. 17.3.70 under sections 148/149/307/302/336/380 of I.P.C. against the following persons and took up investigation of the case.

(1) Ajit Kumar Mukherjee @ Tila (2) Kalyan Dutta Mondal (3) Pabitra Bhattacharjee (4) Madhu (5) Anwar Hossain (6) Akbar Hossain (7) Tapas Mukherjee (8) Vivek (9) Bulu (10) Amal Banerjee (11) Bablu Banerjee (12) Saikat Sain (13) Gandhi (14) Budo (15) Mahadeb Bhattacharjee (16) Swadhin Chatterjee (17) Mridul Sen (18) Salil Bhattacharjee (19) Subhas Chatterjee (20) Dilip Dubey (21) Ajoy Chatterjee (22) Bablu Dutta (23) Pradip Ghosh (24) Baidyanath Samanta (25) Sujit Ghosh (26) Subodh Chowdhury, (27) Amiya Dawn of Shaktigarh, Freedom Fighter Subodh Chowdhury and in the name of others totaling to 72 and 1500 unknown people.

In the original FIR there was no mention of the names of the then MLA Benoy Konar, Gokulananda Roy, Municipal Councillor Mojammel Hossain, Ramnarayan Goswami @ Kudo, Abdul Rashid, Swapan Banerjee and others.

10. Shri Tarun Dutta was the District Magistrate of Burdwan.

11. Later the officiating Chief Minister Shri Sidhartha Shankar Roy had been to Burdwan a number of times. He met the mother of Sain brothers Smt. Mrignayana Devi and made a wide-spread false and malicious propaganda that she was forced to eat boiled rice mixed with blood of her two slain sons on the fateful day. He had also introduced her to Smt. Indira Gandhi.

12. The notorious Governor Dharam Veera also visited Burdwan to give it wide publicity.

13. All the anti-Leftist Forces and a section of perverted media in the country had spread concocted stories of CPI (M) brutality and made it an all India issue.

14. After completion of the investigation the D.D.I., Asansol submitted a charge sheet against 111 persons including Benoy Konar and others on 8.2.71 under various sections of the Penal code including sections 326/302/440/836/114/149/336 of I.P.C. before the S.D.J.M Burdwan.

15. The Investigating Officer requested the Court to release 34 innocent persons who were arrested indiscriminately by him.

16. Out of these 111 accused persons, 56 persons were in jail as Under Trial Prisoners.

17. In this case " STATE V AJIT MUKHERJEE AND 83 OTHERS” also known as the “SAINBARI CASE” there was mention of 78 persons as public witnesses.

18. After submission of the Charge Sheet some more arrests were made.

19. During the running of the trial at Burdwan, the advocate Bhabadish Roy defending the accused, Freedom Fighter Shibshankar Chowdhury (Kalo Da), Purnananda Batabyal, Pancha Bagdi, Ram Mudi, Arun Devbhuti, Nitya Paul, Anwar, Brinta (Bagha), Arun Dutta, Shanti Bhanja and many other CPI (M) leaders & cadres were killed by criminals of Congress Party in Burdwan Town. A total reign of terror was created by the Congress hoodlums and butchers in connivance with Superintendent of Police Panchu Gopal Mukherjee and other police officials in the town.

20. Most of the CPI (M) leaders and cadres living in Burdwan town had fled and took shelter elsewhere.

21. The accused persons, therefore, made a prayer before the Sessions Judge, Burdwan for the transfer of the case outside the Burdwan town on safety and security reasons.

22. The Learned Sessions judge rejected the prayer of the accused persons.

23. Thereafter the accused persons moved the Hon'ble High Court, Calcutta. On 21.2.71 the Hon'ble High Court transferred the case to Alipore and the S.D.J.M Alipore committed the case to the court of Sessions on 13.6.74.

24. Some of the accused persons died in the meantime and some were absconding. So, the Third Court of Additional Sessions Judge Gitesh Ranjan Bhattacharjee framed Charges against 83 accused persons on 13.8.77 including Benoy Konar, Dilip Dubey, Ramnarayan Goswami, Ashok Bhusan Chakraborty, Mridul Sen, Sukanta Konar, Nirupam Sen, Rajat Banerjee, Amiya Saha, Swapan Banerjee under sections 148/149/302/149/436 of IPC and read out their names. All the accused persons pleaded innocence.

25. The names of Amal Haldar and Manik Roy were mentioned neither in the original FIR nor in the charge sheet framed by The Third Court of Additional Sessions Judge on 13-08-1977.

26. In the meantime, the Left Front Government came to power on 21st June, 1977. Immediately after installation, it declared the following policies on the basis of “Forgive and Forget”:

a. No revenge will be taken against those criminals and murderers of the Congress Party who had butchered more than 1200 CPI (M) leaders and cadres in West Bengal between 1971 and1977 and created a reign of terror during this period.

b. All political prisoners irrespective of affiliation would be released unconditionally.

27. On 20.9.77 the Learned Public Prosecutor, therefore, filed an application u/s 321 Cr.P.C seeking the court's consent for withdrawal from the prosecution of the accused persons.

28. On 30-09-1977 Shri Gitesh Ranjan Bhattacharjee heard the case and ordered to withdraw cases against only 4 accused persons.

29. All the other accused persons appealed to the Calcutta High Court. Maintaining the order of 30-09-1977 the Calcutta High Courted directed the State Government to submit afresh a petition before the Third Court of Additional Sessions Judge for withdrawal of the case. Shri Asit Ganguly defended the accused persons.

30. On 29-11-1977 the Public Prosecutor filed an application afresh u/s 321 Cr.P.C before the Third Court of Additional Sessions Judge for withdrawal from the prosecution of the accused persons with the consent of the court on following grounds.

a. There was an occurrence on the relevant date and relevant time in the house of the Sains, but the accused persons did not participate in that occurrence. That most of the accused belonged to one political party and most of the witnesses belonged to a rival political party, and that the accused persons had been falsely implicated in the case. That the investigation had not been fair and impartial and that the rival political party directed the course of the investigation and the evidence collected by the investigation agency was grossly tainted.

b. As two major political parties were involved in the case, if instant prosecution was carried to its logical end, it is almost certain that feelings or acrimony and hatred would be engineered between the local workers of the said two political parties, and that the current (then) situation in Burdwan town is quite peaceful and the trial is bound to disturb the peaceful atmosphere that is prevailing in the town.

c. The then State government (of the Left Front) had effected a policy of "Forgive and Forget" which was directed at putting an end to all political and ideological bitterness of the past.

d. The entire trial is based on the FIR lodged by one Dilip Bhattacharjee. But he himself has declared in writing that he did not know who had committed the murder. He was not a witness to the incident. He had neither written the statement of the FIR nor did he himself submit the same to the concerned police station. The FIR was drafted by the District Congress President Nurul Islam. He had put his signature on the same without going through it. Mr. Islam himself had also submitted it to the police station. The written declaration of Shri Bhattacharjee was enclosed marked Annex-A.

Witness No. 43 Itika Dutta of Suratmahal Lane of Town Hall Para of Burdwan had submitted in writing that during the incident on 17-03-1977 she was out of Burdwan. The Investigating Officer had manufactured a false statement under section 161 Cr.Pc. without meeting her.

The brother of two slain Sain brothers Bijoy Sain submitted in writing that along with two others he was confined to a room during the incident and so did not know what actually had happened.

Bijoy Sain, his sister Swarnalata Josh and brother-in-law Amalkanta Josh had in writing pleaded for withdrawal of the case in view of the prevailing peaceful atmosphere in the town.

e. The Investigating Officer had recorded the statement of Swapan Mukherjee on 08-04-1970, Nurul Islam on 08-04-1970 and Bijoyesh Ganguly on 23-04-1970 as witnesses to the incident but surprisingly their names were not mentioned in the original FIR. Even they had not put their signature on the FIR as witnesses.

The Public Prosecutor submitted that on the basis of such weak documentary evidences and witnesses, it was not possible for him to continue the case against so many people. So, he wanted to withdraw the case.

In the meantime, Hon’ble Judge Gitesh Ranjan Bhattacharjee got transferred to the Calcutta High Court as its judge. So, the Additional Sessions Judge R.K. Kar examined the grounds of withdrawal by looking at similar judicial precedents and on the basis of principles laid down by the Supreme Court in considering such grounds observed that:

a. There was a case of recantation of testimony by the person who filed the FIR.

b. He was unsure of the numbers mentioned in the charge sheet and that following the incident.

c. Leaders of the rival political party had colluded with the investigating officer in getting statements recorded from various witnesses.

d. There were several discrepancies with the statements given by the witnesses.

e. The manner the FIR was filed and in the way the investigation was done.

f. These facts and circumstances supported the Public Prosecutor's submission.

g. The investigation had not been impartial.

h. He would not be able to lead cogent and convincing evidence to warrant a conviction of the accused was not without basis.

i. The general political atmosphere in Burdwan Town at that time, featuring political murders and attacks on rival political parties, the general inaction of the police during the incident - either to halt the miscreants' attack on the Sain house as a retaliation to an alleged bomb attack on them or to apprehend them after the incident.

j. Other precedents on incidents arising out of rivalry between different associations and dismissal of charges owing to the need to continue to maintain harmony post such incidents.

k. In the light of prevalence of relative calm and peace eight years since the Sainbari incident, the judge mentioned that the Public Prosecutor's submission of withdrawal on such grounds deserved consideration.

l. However on the third ground of the Left Front government's policy of "forgive and forget", the judge clearly mentioned that "the policy of Government is no consideration for giving consent for withdrawal" citing other precedents.

m. In sum, the judge considered the other grounds enough to not find sufficient reason to withhold consent for withdrawal. Thus, the 83 accused persons were acquitted of the offences under Cr. PC section 321(b) passing the following order on 06-05-1978.

“CHARGES HAVING BEEN FRAMED AGAINST ACCUSED PERSONS OF THE INSTANT SESSION TRIAL CASE THEY ARE, THEREFORE, ACQUITTED OF THE OFFENCES UNDER SECTION 321 (b) CR.PC.”

If anyone goes minutely through the proceedings of the court, he will come across the following facts.

The "convicts" went on appeal against their "sentence" to the High Court and that eventually they were released on "parole" are thus completely false and flows from the rather flowing imagination of the said author.

It also appears very clearly that the numbers 8 and 17 are discretely chosen to make a scurrilous point.

Amal Haldar's name for example is not part of the 83 accused in the "State vs Ajit Mukherjee..." case.

· How could someone who has not been convicted appeal for "parole"?

· And from where did Bandyopadhyay make his claim that eight persons were convicted and sentenced to "life imprisonment"?

· And why would anyone who has not been "convicted" appeal to the Supreme Court to overturn a judgment of "conviction" if that never happened?

· These are questions that deserve legitimate answers from the obviously deranged former bureaucrat.

· That Bandyopadhyay's later assertions on the CPI (M) using its "power" to grant "parole" to the "convicted" and that the records of the case archive were destroyed are nonsense is proved from the "State vs Ajit Mukherjee..." case records.

· Curiously, Bandyopadhyay also makes other assertions that the Registrar General, Calcutta High Court had "shockingly" reported to the Supreme Court that the High Court had no paper relating to the Sainbari case, when no appeal to the non-existing conviction was ever filed in the High Court!

· The author continues in his nonsensical vein claiming that the "CPI (M) government had granted unconditional and unlimited parole" and hopes that the "Supreme Court gave an order revoking the parole of the convicts".

· It is mentioned in the article that one Joydeep Mukherjee has filed a writ petition before the Supreme Court to find out how the "convicts" have been "enjoying unrestricted and unconditional parole for the last 32 years".

· As established before, these are all false premises and one wonders how the Supreme Court could admit the petition which is certainly a false affidavit - a sure case of contempt of Court.

In fact, the order in the "State vs Ajit Mukherjee and 83 others case" - passed by the Third Court of Additional Sessions Judge, Alipore dated 30 September 1977 and another dated 6 May 1978 - eventually acquitted the 83 accused persons from the charges framed against them.

So, the entire contention of the article written by D. Bandyopadhyay is concocted, manufactured and distorted. It is nothing but a fairy tale and nonsense. It is completely false and flows from the rather flowing imagination of the said author.

The deranged writer D. Bandyopadhyay is a trusted advisor of the leader of the chief party in the opposition in the state is a testament to the state of affairs that exists in the anti-Left Front alliance in West Bengal.

Considering the track record of the leader in question - in the sheer mindlessness, in the nonsensical obstructionism, in the poverty of logic and reason in the Trinamul's politics, it is not a surprise that she keeps such abominable company to advise her. He and other perverts are the “Think Tank” of Mamata Banerjee. It can be easily realized how they are going to destroy the future of West Bengal.

The perverted former bureaucrat D. Bandyopadhyay is the most appropriate successor of “Goebles and Hitler”. If both of them were alive, they would have hung their heads in shame watching their successor surpassing their limits of distortion of facts and perversions. The use of most derogatory words such as “convict on parole”, “public menace”, "killer convicts” “black mamba” “Khokan Sen”, “District level operator” "nasty killer" etc. by this uncultured former bureaucrat speaks of his unsound mind and manner of his bringing up.

It is, therefore, expected that the Supreme Court of India takes drastic steps against the perverted Maoist intellectual D. Bandyopadhyay for distortion of court proceedings and against Joydeep Mukherjee for filing a false affidavit before the Apex Court.

As a matter of fact, the free roaming of these types of perverts and deranged intellectuals is not only dangerous for the society but also for the country.

A section of print media in West Bengal such as “The Statesman”, “Dainik Bartaman”, “Ananda Bazar Patrika”, “Dainik Pratidin”, Dainik Sangbad”, “Mainstream”, “Dainik Ekdin” “The Telegraph” have been emitting venom against the CPI (M), its leaders and the Left Front Government in West Bengal. These print media on the pay roll of finance capital and imperialists are bent upon maligning and weakening the working class and democratic movement in the country. A few perverted anti-national insane intellectuals use these media for suiting their political agenda. The former IAS bureaucrat D. Bandyopadhyay is one of them.

GOPAL KRISHNA GANDHI, BEING A FRIEND, PHILOSOPHER AND GUIDE OF MAMATA BANERJEE-MAOIST-CONGRESS-SUCI ALLIANCE, WAS SOFT TO MAOIST BRUTALITIES

PERVERTED MAOIST-TMC BUTCHERS MURDERED BRUTALLY A DAILY WAGE EARNER BANESWAR MURMU, A TRIBAL, ON 09-09-2009 AT SARENGA IN BANKURA DISTRICT OF WEST BENGAL.

WHAT DO ARUNDHATI DEVI, MEDHA PATKAR, MAHASWETA DEVI AND OTHER INTELLECTUALS HAVING SOFT CORNER, COMPASSION, AFFECTION AND ADMIRATION FOR MAOISTS SAY?

CONSTITUTIONAL LIMITATIONS OF GOVERNORS

According to the Constitution, it is the duty of the Governor to preserve, protect and defend the Constitution and the law and to devote himself to the service and well-being of the people of the state to the best of his abilities.

There is no denying the fact that the Governor is a constitutional head of a state. So, he has two options only. He may call the Chief Minister or any of his Ministers for discussion on any matter which he considers to be serious. The second option is that he may send his report to the Central Government. One eminent Indian Constitutional Expert has very rightly commented that the Governor cannot have any personal view. He has to work within the constitutional limitations. He has no scope for possessing any opinion different from that of the state government.

In Shamsher Singh Vs State of Punjab, the Supreme Court held that the President and the Governors are only constitutional heads and they exercise their power and functions with the aid and advice of the Council of Ministers and not personally. Wherever the constitution requires the ‘satisfaction’ of the President or the Governor, the ‘satisfaction’ is not the personal satisfaction of the President or the Governor but it is the satisfaction of the Council of Ministers.

The pro-imperialist and blind anti-Communist Governor of West Bengal is a man of man of many parts and personality with learning, passion, emotion and compassion. But bad people say that all these qualities are prejudiced and one eyed. He is not so innocent and impartial as he pretends to look. Besides, he is also in possession of an unusual ‘conscience’. It wakes up all on a sudden only when Mamata Banerjee and her rainbow alliance of Maoist-TMC-Congress-SUCI-Few Perverted Intellectuals-Media-NGOs-Human Rights Originations desires and demands in times of need to push their political agenda of overthrowing the Left Front Government in West Bengal. Many people are of the firm opinion that he is a “Friend, Philosopher and Guide” of this alliance and the Governor House has become a centre for hatching political conspiracy against the Left Front Government.

The frequent politically motivated statements issued by him for landing the Left Front Government in constitutional crisis has earned him the unequivocal praise of Mamata Banerjee and her rainbow alliance. To tell the truth, instead of discharging impartially and honestly his duties as a constitutional head, he himself has been in the arena trying to embarrass, heckle and humiliate the Left Front Government and tarnish its image in the estimation of the people throughout the country. He has been instrumental in sabotaging the industrial resurgence of the state. His modus operandi for creating constitutional crisis in the state with the help of the opposition has, therefore, considerably and definitely lowered and damaged the dignity, honour, prestige and status of this august office. It, therefore, not only goes against the spirit of the Constitution but also aimed at subverting it.
The Governors in Andhra Pradesh, Kerala, Bihar, Goa, Jharkhand and West Bengal have acted in gross violation of the Constitution and the law in recent times. People felt outraged by the decisions of the Governors favouring a particular party or coalition. Fortunately the damage caused to the Constitution and to democratic norms was rectified to some extent through the intervention of the Supreme Court, but the damage to the institution of Governors has proved to be irreparable.
It is largely the conduct of a few such Governors that has led to the devaluation of the institution. Some political parties in power both at the Centre and in the States have also contributed to this process of erosion of the prestige and usefulness of the office of governor by having their "own men" in the Raj Bhavans.
Many suggestions have been made by constitutional experts and commissions in order to enable the governors to discharge the duties assigned to them by the Constitution efficiently and satisfactorily. If further erosion of this important institution is to be averted, appropriate corrective measures have to be taken without delay.
Two such measures can be identified as the most important and urgent.
The first is to have a proper system for the selection of persons to be appointed as Governors. An ideal method of selecting suitable persons for governorship is to form a panel of persons in advance from which alone appointments are to be made as and when vacancies arise. Such a panel should be prepared by a high level committee with the Vice-President as Chairman and the Prime Minister, Chief Justice of India, Home Minister and leaders of the Opposition in the two Houses as members. This will help a great deal to increase the credibility of the persons appointed to this high office.
The second important requirement in ensuring impartiality and dignity for the institution of governors is to give them adequate security of tenure. Today the Governor’s post is the least secured among the constitutional posts in the country. Article 156(1) of the Constitution states that a Governor holds his office during the pleasure of the President which in practice means the Prime Minister. Unfortunately, Article 156(1) has been so much misused by the Prime Ministers in the past that the Governor’s position has become in some respects worse than that of an ordinary employee of the Central Government. An employee of the Central Government cannot be removed or dismissed from office without due process, but in the case of Governors, removal can be enforced through "command resignations" as had happened in several cases in the past.
Dr B.R. Ambedkar had assured the Constituent Assembly that there was no need for any special provision in the Constitution for the removal of Governors as such removal will be only in exceptional cases of gross misconduct or violation of the Constitution. His stand, no doubt, reflected the high standards of constitutional propriety and idealism prevalent at the time of the framing of the Constitution. But experience has shown that in the absence of definite provisions in the Constitution for removal of Governors, this power can be misused at the whims and fancies of those in power. A provision, therefore, has to be made in the Constitution laying down the reasons for removal of a Governor and the procedure to be followed for removing him.
If the above two suggestions are adopted as part of the constitutional and administrative reforms promised by the Government it will help a great deal in getting suitable and deserving persons for the post of Governor and curbing the growing tendency among politicians to treat the Governors as just another group among the "employees" of the parties in power.

WB GOVERNOR MUST LEAVE THE STATE FOR INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENT

The pro-imperialist and blind anti-Communist Governor of West Bengal is a man of man of many parts and personality with learning, passion, emotion and compassion. But bad people say that all these qualities are prejudiced and one eyed. He is not so innocent and impartial as he pretends to look. Besides, he is also in possession of an unusual ‘conscience’. It wakes up all on a sudden only when Mamata Banerjee and her rainbow alliance of Maoist-TMC-Congress-SUCI-Few Perverted Intellectuals-Media-NGOs-Human Rights Originations desires and demands in times of need to push their political agenda of overthrowing the Left Front Government in West Bengal. In fact, he is the “Friend, Philosopher and Guide” of this alliance and the Governor House has become a centre for hatching political conspiracy against the Left Front Government.

There is no denying the fact that the Governor is a constitutional head of a state. So, he has two options only. He may call the Chief Minister or any of his Ministers for discussion on any matter which he considers to be serious. The second option is that he may send his report to the Central Government. One eminent Indian Constitutional Expert has very rightly commented that the Governor cannot have any personal view. He has to work within the constitutional limitations. He has no scope for possessing any opinion different from that of the state government.

In Shamsher Singh Vs State of Punjab, the Supreme Court held that the President and the Governors are only constitutional heads and they exercise their power and functions with the aid and advice of the Council of Ministers and not personally. Wherever the constitution requires the ‘satisfaction’ of the President or the Governor, the ‘satisfaction’ is not the personal satisfaction of the President or the Governor but it is the satisfaction of the Council of Ministers.

But the frequent politically motivated statements issued by him for landing the Left Front Government in constitutional crisis has earned him the unequivocal praise of Mamata Banerjee and her rainbow alliance. To tell the truth, instead of discharging impartially and honestly his duties as a constitutional head, he himself has been in the arena trying to embarrass, heckle and humiliate the Left Front Government and tarnish its image in the estimation of the people throughout the country. He has been instrumental in sabotaging the industrial resurgence of the state. His modus operandi for creating constitutional crisis in the state with the help of the opposition has, therefore, considerably and definitely lowered and damaged the dignity, honour, prestige and status of this august office. It, therefore, not only goes against the spirit of the Constitution but also aimed at subverting it.

The tenure of the West Bengal Governor is going to expire very shortly. If he leaves West Bengal, the rainbow alliance will become orphan and guideless. It, therefore, invariably and certainly needs his prejudiced service and some more skillfully drafted public statements similar to those of 15-03-2007 and 09-11-2007 till the next assembly elections going to be held in 2011 so as to dislodge the Left Front Government with his advice, guidance and blessings. So, relentless efforts are already on by them to keep him in West Bengal till the next elections.

If the Central Government tries to keep the most controversial, prejudiced and politically motivated Governor of West Bengal for another term on the recommendations of Mamata Banerjee and her rainbow alliance, it will undoubtedly go against the very spirit of federal fabric of our country and create unnecessary political turmoil in the state.

West Bengal has tolerated him beyond limitations. Enough is enough. The sooner he leaves West Bengal; the better for the industrial resurgence and people of this state.